Tucked away off Oliverea Road in the sleepy hamlet of Big Indian, on a quiet cul-de-sac across the Esopus Creek, this enchanting retreat spans 51.6 deeded acres across two parcels and offers rare privacy amid its NYS Forest Tax Law–managed woodland and meadow. The 1950 three-bedroom, two bath country cottage provides 1,362 sq ft of warm creekside living, complete with a gazebo overlooking the water and a large storage shed. Two deeded State easement trails, one on each side of the property lead through woodland paths to State land behind this property. Along the right-side trail sits a beautiful two-level barn of roughly 750 sq ft, beside a stunning meadow dotted with old fruit trees and home to a picnic table with benches. Built in 2002, the barn replaced a former second home once sited on the 5.9-acre parcel. Altogether, this is a serene Catskills haven where the sound of the Esopus and the sweep of open land create a timeless sense of calm. Ideally located in the Big Indian–Oliverea Valley, this Catskills home places you within 15 to 45 minutes of Belleayre, Plattekill, and Hunter Mountain ski centers—an easy launch point for winter sports. In warmer months, enjoy Belleayre Lake Beach, vibrant farmers markets, and a wide range of celebrated restaurants across nearby hamlets. With some of the region’s most popular Catskill Park trailheads just minutes away, the property is a perfect base for hikers, skiers, and anyone seeking year-round outdoor access in a peaceful mountain setting. Upon entering the great room of this compact and peaceful home, French doors opening to the surrounding deck and large casement windows connect the indoors with views toward the Esopus Creek and the forest trail, where an impressive stand of Eastern Hemlock and yellow birch frames the landscape. Anchoring the great room and cozy dining area is a wood burning stove with a fieldstone surround. The recently renovated kitchen features granite countertops and a breakfast island, opening to a lounge area with a propane fireplace and bay window overlooking the gardens. The home is offered fully turnkey, including most furnishings, decorations, utensils, fixtures, and appliances. For improved forest and wildlife stewardship, the owners enrolled 50 acres of the property in the New York State Forest Tax Law Section 480 A Management Plan. All acreage lies within the NYC Shokan Reservoir designated area. The landowner’s goal is to manage the forest for saw timber and other wood products, enhance wildlife habitat, protect water resources, and maintain recreational value. As a result, the property has been carefully tended to support fishing, tree cultivation, hiking, cross country skiing, nature study, and foraging for berries, mushrooms, and other plants.
Single Family
- Price
- $ 595,000
- City
- Big Indian
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Full Bathrooms
- 2
- County
- ULSTER
- Half Bathrooms
- 0
- Area
- Lot Size
- 51.6 Acres
- Zip
- 12410
- Sqr Footage
- 1,362
- Year Built
- 1950
- Taxes
- $ 5347
- Style
- Cottage
- MLS#
- 1053030
Features
General
Interior Features
Exterior Features
Amenities
- Foreclosure
- Views
- Short Sale
- New Construction
- Adult 55+
- Lease To Own
- No HOA Fees
- Furnished
- Primary On Main
- Air Conditioning
- Seller Finance
- Green
- Fixer Upper
- Horse
- Golf
- Fireplace
- Deck
- Garage
- Basement
- Pool
Affordability Calculator
$3,786
Per MonthBased on the average sale price from the Bay Shore, NY office
- Monthly Principal & interest $2,658
- Monthly Property Taxes $1,062
- Monthly Home Insurance $67
Let's determine your purchasing power. Working with my mortgage partner, you'll have the information you need to shop for a home with confidence.
Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA, or jumbo loans.
Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.
Schools
Price History
Property vs Zip Code Average in 12410
Areas That We Cover
- Albertson
- Amagansett
- Amityville
- Aquebogue
- Atlantic Beach
- Atlantique
- Babylon
- Baiting Hollow
- Baldwin
- Baldwin Harbor
- Baldwin Place
- Bay Shore
- Bayport
- Bayville
- Belle Terre
- Bellerose
- Bellerose Manor
- Bellerose Village
- Bellmore
- Bellport
- Bellport Village
- Bethpage
- Blue Point
- Bohemia
- Brentwood
- Bridgehampton
- Brightwaters
- Brookhaven
- Brookville
- Calverton
- Captree Island
- Carle Place
- Cedarhurst
- Center Moriches
- Centereach
- Centerport
- Central Islip
- Centre Island
- Cherry Grove
- Cold Spring Harbor
- Commack
- Copiague
- Coram
- Cove Neck
- Cutchogue
- Davis Park
- Deer Park
- Dix Hills
- East Atlantic Beach
- East Farmingdale
- East Hampton
- East Hills
- East Islip
- East Marion
- East Meadow
- East Moriches
- East Northport
- East Norwich
- East Patchogue
- East Quogue
- East Rockaway
- East Setauket
- East Williston
- Eastport
- Elmont
- Fair Harbor
- Farmingdale
- Farmingville
- Flanders
- Floral Park
- Fort Salonga
- Franklin Square
- Freeport
- Garden City
- Garden City Park
- Garden City South
- Gilgo Beach
- Glen Cove
- Glen Head
- Glenwood Landing
- Great Neck
- Great Neck Plaza
- Great River
- Greenlawn
- Greenport
- Greenvale
- Halesite
- Hampton Bays
- Hauppauge
- Head Of The Harbor
- Hempstead
- Hewlett
- Hewlett Bay Park
- Hewlett Harbor
- Hewlett Neck
- Hicksville
- Holbrook
- Holtsville
- Huntington
- Huntington Bay
- Huntington Sta
- Huntington Station
- Inwood
- Island Park
- Islandia
- Islip
- Islip Terrace
- Jamesport
- Jericho
- Kensington
- Kings Park
- Lake Grove
- Lake Ronkonkoma
- Lake Success
- Lakeview
- Lattingtown
- Laurel
- Laurel Hollow
- Lawrence
- Levittown
- Lido Beach
- Lindenhurst
- Lloyd Harbor
- Locust Valley
- Long Beach
- Lynbrook
- Malverne
- Manhasset
- Manhasset Hills
- Manorville
- Massapequa
- Massapequa Park
- Mastic
- Mastic Beach
- Matinecock
- Mattituck
- Medford
- Melville
- Merrick
- Middle Island
- Mill Neck
- Miller Place
- Mineola
- Montauk
- Moriches
- Mount Sinai
- Muttontown
- Nesconset
- New Hyde Park
- New Suffolk
- Nissequogue
- North Amityville
- North Babylon
- North Bellmore
- North Haven
- North Hills
- North Lindenhurst
- North Massapequa
- North Merrick
- North Woodmere
- Northport
- Noyack
- Oak Beach
- Oakdale
- Ocean Bay Park
- Ocean Beach
- Oceanside
- Old Bethpage
- Old Brookville
- Old Field
- Old Westbury
- Orient
- Oyster Bay
- Oyster Bay Cove
- Patchogue
- Peconic
- Plainview
- Point Lookout
- Port Jefferson
- Port Jefferson Station
- Port Jefferson Village
- Port Washington
- Quogue
- Remsenburg
- Ridge
- Riverhead
- Rockville Centre
- Rocky Point
- Ronkonkoma
- Roosevelt
- Roslyn
- Roslyn Estates
- Roslyn Harbor
- Roslyn Heights
- Sag Harbor
- Sagaponack
- Saint James
- Saltaire
- Sands Point
- Sayville
- Sea Cliff
- Seaford
- Searingtown
- Seaview
- Selden
- Setauket
- Shelter Island
- Shelter Island Heights
- Shirley
- Shoreham
- Smithtown
- Sound Beach
- South Floral Park
- South Hempstead
- South Huntington
- Southampton
- Southold
- Speonk
- Stewart Manor
- Stony Brook
- Syosset
- Tuckahoe
- Uniondale
- Upper Brookville
- Valley Stream
- Wading River
- Wainscott
- Wantagh
- Water Island
- Water Mill
- West Babylon
- West Hempstead
- West Islip
- West Sayville
- Westbury
- Westhampton
- Westhampton Beach
- Westhampton Dunes
- Wheatley Heights
- Williston Park
- Woodbury
- Woodmere
- Woodsburgh
- Wyandanch
- Yaphank
123 Maben Hollow Road Big Indian, NY is a Single Family Home for sale at $595000 with 1362 sqft and a lot size of 51.6 Acres Acre(s). 123 Maben Hollow Road Big Indian has 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and was built in 1950. The property's zip code is 12410 which is in Big Indian, NY
*Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Financial calculator disclaimer: Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.
Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.
All information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed, and should be independently verified. The real estate information and related content displayed on this site is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.